deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

More from ^Lyricanna in News

Featured in Groups:

Details

August 26, 2012
Sta.sh Writer
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 17
Favourites: 21 [who?]

Views: 1,347 (1 today)
[x]

PE: Colour Count Conundrum

Sun Aug 26, 2012, 11:52 AM



This article is heavily collaborated work between myself and ^ClefairyKid.  The images are all hers, and I thank her for the use of them and the explanations she provided.

We touched on colour count loosely in the first article of the week, here, and it has been mentioned through out since.  And a lot of people don't quite get what the term means, so this should be a thorough explanation.

What is colour count?
To most people, the amount of colours in a piece of art work would be viewed as "I used blue, green and purple, so 3 colours".  In Pixel Art that is not the case; colour count refers to the number of unique values in a piece.  Every shade of blue counts as a separate colour; if your piece is made entirely of 10 shades of blue, you used 10 colours.

Here is a visual example.
and

The first rose was created using pixel techniques as well as layer opacity changes and blend modes.  So while not using any tools that automatically anti-alias, like computerized brushes or gradients, the colour count on this piece did skyrocket. 


This is a zoomed in version of the first pixel rose.  It is hard to pick out individual colours at a glance, but it can be done and we can see that there are a lot.  To find out how many in Photoshop, you can click save for web and devices.*


The colour count is in the bottom of the save for web screen (100% dither, Selective Pallette, 255 colours).  Because this piece hit the limit of colours accepted for a .gif save format, there may have been even more colours than that.  Because of all of these factors, this first piece was placed in the Icons category, where colour count is less important.

The second rose "made with the advice of :devpixelerjeremy: , contains 30 colours, proving that even a piece with lots of different hues need not have too many colours, as the colours used for shadows and highlights can be used create the illusion of working together with other areas of the same picture, which also creates a really nice feeling of harmony throughout the whole images."  (Direct quote from ^ClefairyKid )

Here is the zoomed image:

It is easy to see the number of colours in this piece, compared to the first one.



"Although some might prefer the effects of the first one, others may prefer the effects of the second one, which is the reason we are looking into the definition of the medium in the first place."  One of the questions we posed early on was "how many colours is too many?" because dA does not enforce a colour count.  You can use entirely pixel techniques but then change a layer opacity and no longer have a "traditional" pixel piece.  There are also those that do not use layer opacity changes and still come out with a colour count over 150 unique colours. 

We started a discussion here a month or two ago, and it is an important question for the future of a media that has more options now available to it than when it first started; we have save formats that preserve pixel quality with more colour options than .gif allowed for.  We have tools like the line tool in MS Paint that does not disturb colour count but also means that not every pixel was hand laid.  The standard of a lower colour count is still important to many members of the pixeling community and was held as one of the defining attributes of pixeling in the past, but currently, it is coming under scrutiny from newer members or those that simply enjoy experimenting within the media, that keep to traditional techniques but enjoy the wider range of colours now available.  So we circle back to the importance of clarity and understanding as well as acceptance.

*For those without Photoshop that want to check colour count, Iaza.com is free to use; all you need to do is upload an image and it will give you a colour count read out.

:iconlyricanna:
Sorry for the delay, life happened. This is a collaborative article by ^ClefairyKid and I on what is colour count in pixel art.
Add a Comment:
 
love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconwdwparksgal:
Gorgeous pixel rose!
Added to the PE Section of #DevNews posting August 31st.

Question: when I save an icon or avatar as a gif and optimize to keep the kb to dA's limit, the color values change. Sometimes this affects the quality of the avatar and sometimes it doesn't. Is it because there are more color hues in the work than I thought? There have been times I have removed layers to get an animated avie to look less grainy when keeping it at dA's kb limit.
Reply
:iconlyricanna:
^Lyricanna Aug 29, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
That is a technical question that I cannot answer simply because I make every pixel piece in MS Paint and save as a .png (and do not animate) ^^; I think it is entirely possible that the colours may be compressed, but I would note the question to ^ClefairyKid since she's more familiar with this sort of thing.
Reply
:iconwdwparksgal:
I actually thought I should ask ^ClefairyKid after I sent the comment. It seems to me that the color ranges have something to do with the gifs and how clear or grainy they end up being.
Reply
:iconsingingflames:
=SingingFlames Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
Great article! Just curious, if the first one was placed in the Icons category because the color count is less important, was the second on placed in another category, or is it still an Icon? I figured anything meant to be used as an icon (i.e. the 50x50 size) went into Icons. :confused: Heh, I'm still learning. ^^;

Thanks for putting this together for us! :hug:
Reply
:iconlyricanna:
^Lyricanna Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Both pieces are sized at 50x50 pixels since that was what the commissioner wanted size wise but only the first was used as an icon; the second never was meant to be an icon, just a remake for the sake of improvement, and therefor just pixel art. Since the second was not meant to be used as an icon, it's not one.
Reply
:iconsingingflames:
=SingingFlames Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
Ah, okay. :) Thank you!
Reply
:iconlyricanna:
^Lyricanna Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
You're welcome =)
Reply
:iconmagical525:
=Magical525 Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
Thanks for this - it was very clear :)
Reply
:iconlyricanna:
^Lyricanna Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Glad to hear it =3
Reply
:iconmagical525:
=Magical525 Aug 26, 2012  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
:D
Reply
Add a Comment: